April 23, 2019
Gerard McDermott
New Game Plus / Features

Sony has introduced a new policy regarding sexual content. Japanese developers are reportedly angry and many western gamers are once again convinced that “Social Justice Warriors” have imposed their will on the gaming community. But is this being driven by the return of American Puritanism or is something else going on? It might not be as simple as a culture war or a California-driven plot to change gaming. Some of the biggest recent controversies in gaming and the internet may be all about China.

Business Is A Numbers Game And These Numbers Are Astronomical

Businesses exist to make money, and the videogame industry is business. As a general rule, the bigger the market for your product the more money you can make. With over 1.3 billion people the potential market for videogames in China is astronomical compared to all previous markets.

China has an estimated 620 million people currently playing videogames. That means China’s videogame market is larger than the entire population of the United States, Japan, the UK and Australia combined. In 2018 the Chinese videogame market was worth 38 billion dollars out of a world total of 138 billion dollars. The profit that can be made from that many gamers will dwarf anything previously made in the traditional western markets, so it should be no surprise that the big videogame publishers and developers want a part of it.

But working in China is not as simple as in other countries. The Chinese government knows that overseas companies desperately want access to their people and they use that to make sure external companies follow their rules. The impact of some of those rules might look familiar.

Toxic Chat and Revealing Costumes – China’s Online Games Ethics Committee

Any on-line videogame that wants to be released in China needs to be approved by an Online Games Ethics Committee. This committee was formed in 2017 and in its first year the Committee reviewed only 20 games and rejected 9 of them outright. Here are some of the reasons given for banning some well known games:

League of Legends – “Overly revealing female characters, rewards given based on rank, inharmonious chatroom.”

Overwatch – “Game visuals promote incorrect values, inharmonious chatroom.”

Diablo – “Inharmonious chat, game missions include fraud.”

World of Warcraft – “Overly revealing female characters, inharmonious chatroom.”

Notice the trend.

Is it just a co-incidence that the last few years has seen a lot of controversy here in the west about how female videogame characters are dressed or about “toxic” on-line discussion boards? Or has the industry been preparing to move into the Chinese market? There are definitely true believers in these causes here in the west, but companies like Blizzard are making their decisions about character presentation and on-line communities with an eye on what they need to do to be approved by China’s Ethics Committee.

Anonymity – China’s Social Credit Score

China is using concern about videogame addiction as a method of expanding surveillance over its citizens. It has been announced that Tencent Holdings will require all players of its mobile and personal computer games to verify their identities against police databases from 2019 as part of its attempts to assuage government concern that excessive gaming is hurting the health of the country’s young.

Who is Tencent? Tencent owns Epic Games (Epic Games Store, Fortnite), Riot Games (League of Legends), and Supercell (Clash of Clans, Boom Beach, Clash Royale, Brawl Stars). Tencent also owns WeChat which is China’s major social media app with 1 billion monthly active users (902 million active daily users).

Last year the World Health Organisation in its disease classification manual stated that compulsively playing video games qualifies as a mental health condition. The Chinese government has described videogames as the new Opium – a description referring to a British plot to destroy the productivity of the country in the 1800’s by flooding it with opium. The British even went to war twice with China to force them to accept the drug.

Verifying your identity against a police database just to play a game sounds extreme, but it is about making sure that players can not be anonymous. Why are the Chinese so against internet anonymity?

China is implementing a social score system that ranks everybody according to how good a citizen they are. This includes how they behave on-line. That system does not work if people are allowed to take part in any activity anonymously.

There is some common ground between the Chinese government and all the blue checkmarks on Twitter who want internet anonymity removed – to make it easier to punish people for what they deem bad behaviour.

This is a dangerous step because “bad behaviour” means different things in different places of the world and in different contexts – whistleblowers in the west, dissidents in the middle east, bloggers in cartel-ruled Mexico, and LGBT people in countries with a heavy religious influence on law-making all have valid reasons to keep their identities private when on-line.

Despite the risks, the Chinese government demands it so tech and videogame companies have to bend to them if they want to operate in that country.

A Gaming Culture That Grew Up With Micro-transactions & Lootboxes

Videogame consoles were banned in China until 2015. That means Chinese console gaming culture does not remember a time before DLC, microtransactions and lootboxes. What is jarring and obnoxious in western markets is normal for Chinese gamers. Combine that with a very large mobile gaming market – mobile games are already worth 2/3rds of the Chinese videogame market – and you have a gaming culture that is nowhere near as hostile to the worst publisher and developer monetisation schemes. In some cases they may even embrace it.

Even if only a small percent of Chinese gamers find paying money in their games acceptable, that still means tens of millions of gamers effectively voting with their wallets for DLC, microtransactions and lootboxes. Some studies suggest that up to 94% of paying gamers in China spend money on in-game purchases. About 60% if that is on costumes for in-game characters.

Weight of numbers means the Chinese market will dictate what videogame monetisation schemes are acceptable and what is not, and the rest of us will have to accept it. For the publishers and developers it is effectively an opportunity to re-boot the industry again in conditions that are better for them to make money.

So get ready for a lot of changes that you might not like, because the truth is that the old western markets are so small by comparison that they may not influence many decisions by videogame publishers and developers in the future. We have already seen big changes in how female game characters are dressed and we are already seeing companies like Blizzard implement draconian steps to try to clean up their on-line communities. The “Social Justice Warriors” and their enemies on social media may be fighting in a war that does not ultimately involve them. As with the push to remove on-line/in-game anonymity and the continued prevalence of predatory monetisation, this may be a war that none of us will be able to affect the outcome of. For the foreseeable future, western gamers are at the mercy of a combination of Chinese government regulation and Chinese consumer buying habits.

May 2, 2019

Once upon a time the writing in videogames was pretty bad. These days videogames have some of the best stories out of all entertainment mediums. Sometimes a videogame will throw something at you so confronting or emotional that it stays with you forever. Here are my 5 favourite moments in videogames that reminded why I love them so much. Life Is Strange – Chaos Theory “Chloe! You have a visitor!” Life is Strange is about two young women Max and Chloe who are trying to solve the mystery disappearance of Chloe’s friend. The hook in this game is an extremely well executed ...

March 4, 2019

Here’s a quick look at the 3rd quarter reports for some of the big Japanese game companies for the financial year ending 31st March 2019.   Nintendo continues to exceed expectations, with net sales up 16.4%, operating profit up 40.6% and ordinary profit up 23.5%. A good holiday season saw almost 15 million Switches sold this year, with Smash Ultimate selling 12 million and the Pokemon Let’s Go games selling 10 million. Smash Ultimate was the main driver of new Switch Online subscriptions, although many new subscribers chose shorter terms like single month subscriptions. No m...

February 7, 2019

Did you know that the Nintendo 3DS is eight years old? It’s weird to think about, and it sure makes me feel old. Although the little system becomes overshadowed more every year by its newer sibling, the Nintendo Switch, it’s still the chosen platform for some spectacular game releases that wouldn’t really fit anywhere else. Mario & Luigi: Bowser’s Inside Story + Bowser Jr’s Journey is one of those games. When the original Bowser’s Inside Story released in 2009 for the Nintendo DS, it was praised for how well it used the system’s dual screens; shifting between perspectives is visu...

November 20, 2018

Luigi’s Mansion is, for various reasons, one of my favourite games of all time. I’ve finished it at least six or seven times since its 2001 release, including an almost-complete gold portrait run, and I’ll jump at any chance to replay it (though not as much as a friend of mine, who’s finished the game 31 times). The trailer for the 3DS version filled me with equal parts excitement and apprehension: It’s now accessible for a new generation, but how can you improve on the original game’s simple perfection? Once again, I picked up the flashlight and ventured into Luigi’s Mansion. T...

August 26, 2018

If I told you to imagine a game where you smash pots and whack baddies with your sword, what would you think of? How about a game where you use items to solve dungeon puzzles, and collect all sorts of goodies along the way? Well, it’s not the game you’re thinking of…probably. It’s something a bit more off-beat, with more ‘rainbow’ than ‘bow and arrow’: It’s The Swords of Ditto, a roguelike action-adventure RPG developed by Onebitbeyond. Your game begins with you being awakened on the beach (strong Link’s Awakening vibes here) by Puku, a mysterious beetle-like creature....

June 13, 2018

After some great and not so impressive conferences at this year’s E3, Nintendo was highly anticipated to bring us some juicy news. With the potential for some much wanted first-party titles for Switch, I stayed up until past 2am with high hopes for news on Pokémon, Animal Crossing, and more. With caffeine and sugar in my system, my body was ready. Like previous years, this year’s presentation followed the Nintendo Direct format,. The show began starting on a less colourful note with Demon X Machina, a mecha game for the Switch. Following this was Xenoblade 2 Story DLC ‘Torna –...

June 12, 2018

In my first year of university, I saw a jock-looking dude walking around wearing his ‘Class of 2005’ high school top; nothing out of the ordinary, I was sure he was well beloved by his peers. In my final week of study, I saw that same guy wandering around the campus by himself, slumped shoulders still adorned by that very same top — this was in 2009. Sony’s E3 Showcase this year reminded me of that guy still clinging to the glory of past years. This was most evident during the special presentation for The Last of Us Part II. This was Sony at its most self-indulgent. It gathered gu...

Still broke shirt $15

You can support New Game Plus AND look good by wearing our awesome merchandise.

This black t-shirt says:

300 Rupee.
5,000 Gil.
7,000 Septum.
800 Bottlecaps.
10,000 Bison Dollar.

Still broke.


June 12, 2018

Ubisoft is one of the few gaming monoliths that can still surprise us. Who would’ve thought that Assassin’s Creed: Origins would mark the franchise’s return to form? Who could’ve predicted  the critical successes of Mario + Rabbids: Kingdom Battle? This was reflected in previous years through Ubisoft’s E3 presentations, which were always the most interesting and unpredictable, backed by an sincerity unmatched by any other company. It’s curious, then, to see Ubisoft pump the brakes with this year’s showing. Beyond Good and Evil 2 closed off last year’s show, so it’s fitting ...

June 11, 2018

Bethesda had an interesting 2017. Despite a lacklustre trip to Bethesdaland and reports that several of its games didn’t meet sales targets, the company was still the number one publisher on Metacritic, a fact proudly claimed by Senior VP of Global Marketing Pete Hines. Though if this year’s E3 press conference is any indication, 2018 and beyond are going to be very big and important years for the publisher. The show kicked off quite literally with a bang as inspirational speaker Andrew W.K. and his band introduced us to to the recently unveiled Rage 2, as well as endless shots of aud...

Show More Blogs
Latest Videos
Latest Photos & Events